 |
::
Stakeholders > 2004
AISI Media Awards > Winners & Finalists
|

|
AISI/GTZ Media Awards 2004 - PRINT
"Promoting the Information Society in Africa"
|
Winner:
Eteka Coutchika
Cyrille (Benin)
"La revolution technologique de l'espoi"
This
article is comprehensive and technically very informative.
In addition, the writer balances a difficult technical
analysis of radio and television diffusion with economic
and political issues, arguing in favour of the open
society. This is a well-researched piece with attention
to detail and factual analysis of questions that should
impact not only Africa but also the Planet, and the
developing world in particular.
The writer's knowledge is indisputable, and his writing
is scholarly and informed. He is a powerful voice
for positive ICT developments in his country and Africa
as a whole. The article is not written for the man
in the street, but for the informed reader interested
in telecommunications developments on the continent.
Some considerations he is making are critical to make
sure Africa reaps most benefits from ICTs. |
Runner-Up
Aloyce Menda (Tanzania)
"Controversies over ICT benefits to Africa"
The article
breaks ground, providing information that is not widely
known. This report does just this with its focus on
the consequences technology has on the developing
world. The story is well articulated, easy to understand
and promotes an understanding of another aspect of
technology - the environmental and human costs.
The article focuses on the role precious Coltan ore
plays in conflict in DRC. This is the sort of story
that is not often found in western media. Few citizens
in the west are aware that much of the Coltan illegally
stolen from Congo is in their laptops, cell phones
and electronic devices. This is an important article,
bringing to the fore an aspect of ICTs that is dealt
with all too seldom in the media. |
|
  |
AISI/GTZ Media Awards 2004 - RADIO
"Promoting the Information Society in Africa"
Winner:
Filifing Diakite (Mali)
"Programme on Telemedicine - Radio Guintan 94.7 FM"
The programme
manages to make this rather technical and scientific topic
easily understandable to the non-expert listener. This is
good journalism. Various voices are heard, giving a spectrum
of opinion and ensuring one is not subjected to a monotone.
This is good radio. The programme spreads useful information
to citizens, and helps to give a more nuanced understanding
of the potential of ICTs in assisting social development.
|

|
AISI/GTZ Media Awards 2004 - TV
"Promoting the Information Society in Africa"
|
Winner:
Adri Joseph Gnassengbe
(Togo)
"Efforts de vulgarisation des TIC au Togo"
The documentary
includes on-site reporting, opening with a teacher demonstrating
in an outdoor classroom the potential of technology.
We learn about the benefits and the problems of technology
in this rural part of Togo - including problematic electricity
and illiteracy. Broader community voices would make
this a significantly stronger report.
The documentary is people focused. We see students at
a Catholic school crowded around some computers, which,
surprisingly, are on tables outdoors. The children are
clearly very interested, and the visuals make it quite
clear that this is a school with hardly any resources
at all. The viewer is left in no doubt about the importance
contribution that Internet connected computers will
make to their education. The discussion deals partly
with problems of illiteracy in rural areas and the consequent
problems related to providing ICT access, and also looks
at cybercafe usage and possibilities for people to get
computer skills training.
|
Runner-Up
Salif
Sanogo (Mali)
CyberNTIC "Special Geneve 2003"
This
program is extensively reported, professionally produced
and well edited. The story focuses on the potential
technology has to help the people of Mali and all of
Africa. And, importantly, the documentary highlights
the ideas of Senegalese president Abdoulaye Wade relating
to the need for digital solidarity. Sanogo is not only
professional, but he also demonstrates insight of the
issue. He has been covering ICTs issues for many years. |
|
 
|
AISI/IICD Media Awards 2004
"Local Content"
|
Joint
Winners:
Bavesh Baijnath,
Digital Dimension
(Mauritius)
http://www.mauritiusportal.com
The portal
has a variety of information, and provides feed back
opportunity to the surfers. This portal has a lot of
information. It has everything from world news to currency
conversion information against a non-local currency.
The website seems to have focused more on global issues.
Shina
Badaru
Technology Times (Nigeria)
http://www.techtimesnews.net
This is
a new Nigerian website with much promise. The editor(s)
obviously takes interaction seriously. Every article
has a prominent sidebar where readers can post their
comments. The site also encourages readers to submit
their own ICT related articles. As a regular writer
the site has journalist Shina Badaru, a well-known ICT
commentator who has a large group of loyal readers.
This bodes well for the future of the site. Badaru combines
expert knowledge with an incisive writing style and
a great sense of humour. The layout is clean and simple,
with easy-to-read text. The content is professional.
This portal uses the web technology to exchange ICT
related knowledge among community members and update
the community members on developments in the Nigerian
ICT industry. The portal has a discussion space where
local users can discuss about ICT related issues relevant
to their community such as the effect of Microsoft's
presence in Nigeria, its piracy campaign and its contribution
to the country. This feature encourages the generation
or sharing of local knowledge. It uses the official
language of Nigeria as a medium of communication.
|
Runner-Up
Zaid
Al-Mosheky, EthioMarket
e-Web Technology (Ethiopia)
http://www.ethiomarket.com
This is
a very focused and impressive website. It is the only
of its kind in Ethiopia and is a comprehensive guide
to market-related information in the country. The site
has a pleasing layout and is most professionally implemented
with clear navigation. It uses an ICT application (website)
to express expert and detailed knowledge of the Ethiopian
market. This website uses the web technology to provide
information about Ethiopian market to local users as
well as foreign investors. It has a lot of content focusing
mainly on the import/export sector. It has a variety
of important information that is helpful to local users,
such as contact information, relevant links and local
bids. The website has a good design and organization.
|
|
  |
AISI/IDRC Media Awards 2004
"Reporting on ICT Research and Innovation"
|
Winner:
Arthur Okwemba (Kenya)
''African women virtually excluded''
It is
well known that many ICT projects in Africa that focus
on women fail to meet the expectations of their initiators.
This article points to one of the causes - implementers
have failed to take cognizance of key cultural factors
such as power relations between men and women.
The paper is very informative, entertaining for some
and provide in-depth Africa trends as well as challenges.
It is a model of what should be done. The paper summarises
some important research into Internet usage by men and
women in six African countries. Despite presenting a
lot of relative statistics, the author manages to keep
the reader interested and attentive. Media need to bring
to the forefront information that can assist in planning
more realistic ICT projects, and this article does just
this.
It is well documented; it addresses the issue of women
access to ICT in small communities in a comprehensive
manner.
|
Runner-Up
Wanjohi
Kabukuru (Kenya)
"ICTs: key to Africa's rapid rural progress"
The article
provides good facts about some of the activities of
the Arid Lands Information Network Eastern Africa ALIN-EA.
The NGO has more than 1000 community development worker
members in Eastern Africa. It has established more than
30 community information centres in the region. It is
collaborating with NGOs in an Open Knowledge project
to disseminate health information. |
|
  |
AISI/IDRC Media Awards 2004
"Reporting on ICT Policy"
|
Winner:
John Patrick Mireny
(Tanzania)
"Why harmonizing ICT policies could catalyse Africa"
This
is a piece that brings out memories of extreme frustration
lived by anyone who has gone through this kind of situation
before. It demonstrates the daily limitations to which
professionals in the developing world are exposed. Government
policies can actually bar individuals from developing
to their full potential.
From a sad experience, after an event close to what
we are doing, he exposed calmly but very powerfully
the need to harmonize policy in the regions. His paper
renders a great deal of tribute to the various researches
led in the sector with the help of various organizations.
He demonstrates that African researchers bring useful
contribution to the understanding and ultimately policy
making in ICTs in Africa.
The story presents a clear deficiency in technology
potential throughout all of Africa. The reporter takes
a complex topic and makes it relatively understandable.
Mireny uses the clever device of introducing a complex
topic - the harmonisation of regional ICT policies -
with the simple easy-to-understand story of an award-winning
journalist who has his computer prize impounded by customs
officials. He then proceeds to deal quite thoroughly
with the problematic of policy harmonisation.
This story focuses on a vital aspect of ICT policy that
impacts on regional integration: the fiscal leverage
system and how it hampers the development of ICTs in
Africa. It is informative and keeps in mind the broader
picture of integration.
|
Runner-Up
Emmanuel
Onyango (Tanzania)
"Towards a community-driven information"
The story
is clearly written and explains what technology has
been and should be used for in improving quality of
living. This is a well-back grounded piece that shows
sensitivity to issues of accountability, good governance,
the roles of the State and civil society in the exchange
and dissemination of information. The article implies
that low cost and pro-IT government policies have led
the country towards IT-oriented education policies.
The article is well written, nicely mixes analysis and
the reporter's own knowledge, and presents an extremely
easy explanation of what ICT is. It clearly explains
the potential of technology for businesses in a developing
environment. It takes a local approach while also mentioning
the potential throughout sub-Saharan Africa.
|
|

OSIWA |
AISI/OSIWA Media Awards 2004
"Reporting ICTs and Rural Communities"
|
Winner:
Baba Thiam (Senegal)
"NTICs en milieu rural - Ngoundiane veut souder
la fracture numérique entre les villes et les
Campagnes''
A technology
story that isn't all boosterism and industry jargon!
The story presents a clear problem with balance and
thorough reporting. The reporter uses a single community,
Ngoundiane, to demonstrate national problems - and potential.
The author places his erudite discussion in a historical
perspective, reminding us of the north/south debates
around the New World Information Order, the more recent
concepts of the digital divide and the 'global village',
and the need for technological transfer. His article
considers the 'timid' penetration of ICTs into rural
areas, focusing on a somewhat failed project in rural
Ngoundiane in Senegal. He reminds us of the problems
of inadequate telecom infrastructure, of rural illiteracy,
and of the important need to conceive rural ICT projects
on a realistic basis.
|
Runner-Up
Adetokunbo Abiola
(Nigeria)
" Taking Internet to the Grassroots''
This well
written story clearly explains what benefits rural communities
could get from the use of the Internet in their daily
lives. It deals with some of the clichés (reminding
the reader that rural people are not necessarily illiterate)
and also presents community-based projects to give access
to these communities to the Internet. |
|

OSIWA |
AISI/OSIWA Media Awards 2004
"Best Female Reporter on ICT Issues"
|
Winner:
Rosemary Okello
(Kenya)
"Yes to ICTs, but fit them to our practical needs"
This opinion/analysis
piece points to the development of a coherent ICT policy
that takes into account cultural precepts as central
to any country that is serious about education, and
by extension democratisation.
The story takes a pertinent topic that blends social,
education and technology issues. The reporter raises
good issues and gives the story continent-wide pertinence.
The article is professionally crafted, articulate and
well-informed. The author pulls together important concepts
and convincingly presents her argument. It links ICTs
with socio-economic development. There is analytical
depth based on knowledge of ICTs. The story articulates
the needs of women in emerging info society. The article
is educative, and promotes understanding, and it is
clear, well-articulated and convincing. |
Runner-Up
Ellen
Muleya Chikale (Zambia)
"Zambia Keen to be part of global IT"
The author
provides a clear, comprehensive of Zambia's efforts
to keep up with the global information society. It is
quite narrative, but very comprehensive. Could do with
more factual information.
Ellen Chikale's journalism has a refreshing enthusiasm
that keeps the reader attentive to the end. Zambians
are well served by her articles in the Daily Mail, which
explicate aspects of ICTs in that country.
|
|
|
|
|
 |